• Home
  • Subscribe
    • Staff
    • Comment Section
    • Submitting Articles and News Stories
  • Articles
  • News
  • Apologetics
    • By Month
    • By Author
    • Articles
    • News
  • Contact
Menu

Fulcrum7

3230 US Route 36
Piqua, OH 45356
937-773-8235
Publishing Articles & News items

Your Custom Text Here

Fulcrum7

  • Home
  • Subscribe
  • About
    • Staff
    • Comment Section
    • Submitting Articles and News Stories
  • Articles
  • News
  • Apologetics
  • Archives
    • By Month
    • By Author
    • Articles
    • News
  • Contact
44.5.png

Articles

What if Criticism is a Signal?

August 9, 2026 Wyndi Ambrose

The other day SDA Pastor Ivor Myers published a viral post calling public criticism of the church “satanic”.

His gripe, it seems, isn’t particularly about having issues with the church but rather with discussing them in public forums where “unbelievers” could potentially have access to our dirty laundry.

To tell you the truth, I was conflicted when I read the post.

Because on one hand, I’m asking myself, “Isn’t this the same guy who tried to convince people that an entire time signature in music was monopolized by the devil -- his only credibility being that he’s a former rapper? Can we trust the opinion of someone whose logic is questionable?”

And on the other hand, I’m thinking, “He’s right. Some people do seem to feed off controversy, and the conversations they bring into the spotlight seem to have little to do with elevating the SDA culture.”

But then I started to ask myself:

Why do so many SDA leaders seem so threatened by public criticism?

And what if instead of viewing it as a personal attack, treason, or betrayal – what if they started viewing it as a signal? What if they viewed it as an opportunity, even?

Take for example, this Instagram video that two people in my circle sent me recently.

 
 

The young woman in the video explains that although she grew up in the Seventh-day Adventist Church, she developed a much deeper understanding of the importance of having a relationship with God after attending Sunday-worshipping churches as an adult. She describes finding a culture of fellowship, community, and genuine connection that she says she rarely experienced growing up Adventist.

She also says/hinted that she feels the Adventist Church, in general, is “outdated,” resistant to fresh ideas, and disconnected from the needs of young people.

Now, if you’re a leader watching something like this, you have a choice.

You could get offended and mentally begin listing every youth program your conference has ever organized.

Or...

You could see it as an opportunity.

This thing got more than 14K likes and 1,314 reshares. So clearly the message resonated with many people.

As a leader, that’s your signal. That’s your opportunity to understand how many people are really feeling and to respond with compassion – not criticize them for having opinions or sharing their experiences.

What if a video like this prompted you to:

  • Create an anonymous survey for the young people in your church asking them to react to the video and share what would help them feel more connected to your local church family.

  • Pivot your upcoming Sabbath sermon, using the conversation as a starting point to explore practical ways we can create deeper relationships within the church.

  • Reach out to local social workers and youth counselors to better understand the biggest struggles young people in your community are facing, then create sermons, Bible studies, or social media content that speaks directly to those realities.

Would that make you a weak leader who caves to criticism? Or a thoughtful leader who leverages it as an opportunity to better serve the people entrusted to your care?

You know, the Ivor Myers characters among us might argue that these conversations should remain internal.

And honestly?

In an ideal world, I might even agree.

But let’s be real.

When we do have these conversations internally, how often does anything actually change?

I think about the countless “strategic plans” to reach young people. Yet when it’s time to make decisions, there often isn’t a single young person sitting at the table. And if there are young people involved, they often seem to be the ones selected by the establishment because they already fit a particular mold.

The result? Little diversity of thought and the same, old patterns of ministry struggling to survive in a rapidly changing world.

I think there’s hope though. But it requires a different mindset.

Think of it this way:

If the church were a business and someone left a negative online review after a bad experience, we’d follow many of the same customer service principles successful organizations use every day. We’d respond thoughtfully. We’d try to understand what happened. We’d evaluate whether there were legitimate issues buried beneath the frustration. We’d use that feedback to improve the experience for the next person.

Ok…So, why don’t we approach criticism of the church the same way?

Of course, not every criticism has merit. Some complaints are unfair. Some people are simply looking for attention. But as an organization that’s supposed to be focused on people and can’t survive without people, I would argue that the burden falls on leaders to thoughtfully evaluate criticism before dismissing it outright. Interestingly enough, Scripture gives us a model for this.

In Acts 15, the early church found itself in the middle of a serious disagreement over Gentile converts. Some believers insisted that Gentiles needed to be circumcised and keep the law of Moses. Paul and Barnabas strongly disagreed, and eventually the issue was brought before the apostles and elders in Jerusalem.

What strikes me is what happened next.

They didn’t pretend the controversy didn’t exist. They gathered. They listened. They debated. Peter spoke about what he had witnessed among Gentile believers. Paul and Barnabas shared what they had seen God doing in their ministry. James weighed the testimony and Scripture. And ultimately, the church changed its approach, deciding not to place requirements on Gentile believers that its leaders concluded God wasn’t asking of them.

The controversy wasn’t treated as an enemy of the church. It became an opportunity for the church to listen, discern, clarify, and grow.

And no, Acts 15 doesn’t give us some sanitized picture of leaders who suddenly became perfect at handling disagreement. By the end of the chapter, Paul and Barnabas themselves have such a sharp disagreement over John Mark that they part ways. These were still very human people.

But that doesn’t make the earlier example less meaningful. In fact, we learn that Scripture doesn’t require leaders to be conflict-free. It shows us that when an issue affecting the people they serve comes to the surface, they can choose to engage it thoughtfully rather than simply silence it. And to me, that is a very different posture than simply labeling public criticism as “satanic.”

Maybe the bigger question isn’t whether criticism belongs on Facebook, Instagram, or behind closed doors. Maybe the bigger question is this:

When people tell us they’re struggling, what do we do with that information?

We can dismiss it because it was shared in the “wrong” place. We can question the motives of the person speaking. Or we can ask whether God might be using uncomfortable voices to reveal blind spots we’ve stopped seeing.

Not every criticism will be valid. Not every complaint deserves action. But if we’re serious about reaching people, shouldn’t we be just as interested in understanding why people are leaving as we are in convincing them to stay?

Because sometimes criticism isn’t an attack.

Sometimes it’s a signal.

And faithful leaders don’t just defend the mission. They listen carefully enough to strengthen it.

****

 

Wyndi Ambrose lives in Christiansted, US Virgin Islands with her husband Salvador Felix and two children. A thoughtful writer, Wyndi operates a Substack titled Reverent Questions. She writes in her spare time, (when the children are alseep).

← Seventh-day Adventists or Spiritualists?Few in Number (Part 3) →
Send Fulcrum7 a News Tip !
 
Featured
No Response From Michigan Conference To Coloma SDA Church's Request for NAD Action on LGBTQ+ Institutional Compromise
November 17, 2026
Gerry Wagoner
No Response From Michigan Conference To Coloma SDA Church's Request for NAD Action on LGBTQ+ Institutional Compromise
November 17, 2026
Gerry Wagoner

The (Michigan) Conference will consider the request at an Executive Committee meeting, and forward it to the North American Division.

Read more →
November 17, 2026
Gerry Wagoner
A Denominational Storm in Australia Over Watagan Park Central Shopping Centre
November 13, 2026
Concerned SDA Church Members
A Denominational Storm in Australia Over Watagan Park Central Shopping Centre
November 13, 2026
Concerned SDA Church Members

This has created an untenable situation where non-SDA residents view our Church as the primary culprit operating with clear double standards.

Read more →
November 13, 2026
Concerned SDA Church Members
Veterans' Day and the White Coats
November 11, 2026
David Read
Veterans' Day and the White Coats
November 11, 2026
David Read

Today is Veterans’ Day, honoring our veterans. It began as Armistice Day, commemorating the end of the First World War. I would like to honor the Seventh-day Adventists who served in “Operation White Coat.”

Read more →
November 11, 2026
David Read
Michigan Unilaterally Assigns Pastor to Village Church Without Input From Congregation
November 8, 2026
NewsHound
Michigan Unilaterally Assigns Pastor to Village Church Without Input From Congregation
November 8, 2026
NewsHound

A new pastor has been unilaterally assigned to Village. This is the second time that a pastor has been unilaterally assigned to Village without any input from anyone at the Village SDA Church.

Read more →
November 8, 2026
NewsHound
Southern Adventist University VP Dennis Negrón Resigns After Inappropriate Content Shows up on his Social Media Account
November 6, 2026
NewsHound
Southern Adventist University VP Dennis Negrón Resigns After Inappropriate Content Shows up on his Social Media Account
November 6, 2026
NewsHound

After Shaw’s announcement of Negrón’s resignation, Ingrid Skantz, vice president of Marketing and University Relations, stated in an email to the Accent that administration had conducted an investigation.

Read more →
November 6, 2026
NewsHound
The Woke Era is Far From Over, 8 Transgender Candidates Win US Elections
November 6, 2026
ChurchMouse
The Woke Era is Far From Over, 8 Transgender Candidates Win US Elections
November 6, 2026
ChurchMouse

Men in frocks and makeup taking seats meant for women, and the pious throng clapping as if it were progress rather than the falling away (2 Timothy 3).

Read more →
November 6, 2026
ChurchMouse
The Upper Columbia Conference Headquarters is Listed For Sale at 15 Million Dollars
November 4, 2026
NewsHound
The Upper Columbia Conference Headquarters is Listed For Sale at 15 Million Dollars
November 4, 2026
NewsHound

The listing follows broader cost-restructuring efforts by the Upper Columbia Conference, which noted a $3 million organizational budget shortfall heading into 2025.

Read more →
November 4, 2026
NewsHound
NAD Leaders Discuss Tithe Policies and Possible Organizational Restructuring
October 30, 2026
NewsHound
NAD Leaders Discuss Tithe Policies and Possible Organizational Restructuring
October 30, 2026
NewsHound

Proposed next steps include studying organizational efficiency and restructuring and beginning the process for changing tithe reversion policies.

Read more →
October 30, 2026
NewsHound
Oakwood University Stabbing
October 26, 2026
NewsHound
Oakwood University Stabbing
October 26, 2026
NewsHound

Dameesha Macklin, 25, of Houston, Texas, used a knife to assault the victim (a student) during an altercation. Macklin is a student at Oakwood University.

Read more →
October 26, 2026
NewsHound
Amish Woman in Pennsylvania Fends off Illegal Alien Kidnapper With Her Weedeater
October 25, 2026
Gerry Wagoner
Amish Woman in Pennsylvania Fends off Illegal Alien Kidnapper With Her Weedeater
October 25, 2026
Gerry Wagoner

The same voices that for years insisted open borders were compassionate now confront the reality that compassion without borders is not compassion at all. It is the transfer of risk onto people who asked for nothing more than to live their life in peace.

Read more →
October 25, 2026
Gerry Wagoner
Summary Block
This block is invalid. Please check the block settings and try again.
Featured
Aenean eu leo Quam
Aenean eu leo Quam

Quisque iaculis facilisis lacinia. Mauris euismod pellentesque tellus sit amet mollis.

Read more →

© FULCRUM7